DIVING into debt, Katie and Brett Nash are living the great Australian dream. Having boarded with Katie’s parents for a year to save a deposit, the Brisbane couple borrowed $350,000 to buy a four-bedroom brick house with a big back yard in the outer bayside suburb of Alexandra Hills in Brisbane six weeks ago.
But Brett then lost his job as a cement truck driver, so his wife is spending half her take-home pay as a nurse to meet the $1900-a-month mortgage. Despite the difficulties, the Nashes are delighted they will no longer have to pay “dead rent” to a landlord.
“You’ve got to get into the market some time,” Katie reasons. “It’s for security. We were paying out dead money in rent – I paid $17,000 in rent one year – but buying is an investment.”
Brett, 28, does not feel that his life is any tougher than that of his grandparents’ self-sacrificing generation. “I think a lot of people these days are probably a bit more selfish and want everything,” he says.
“Our grandparents wouldn’t have contemplated things like travelling or spending $500 on a pair of shoes. Nowadays there’s more to be had, and everyone wants everything now.”
The Nashes are among a record number of Australians who took on a mortgage in April, as first-home buyers rushed to cash in on the federal government’s first-home buyers grant ($14,000 for established homes and $21,000 for new properties) before it is phased out from September.
Despite staggering under historically high costs of housing, generation Y has not lost any of the enthusiasm for home ownership that seems embedded in the Australian psyche.
The trend worries Julian Disney, director of the Social Justice Project at the University of NSW and chairman of the National Affordable Housing Summit, a coalition of housing industry and community organisations. He fears that historically low interest rates and high government subsidies are luring young home buyers into a false security. “At the moment prices are still high but interest rates are low, so it looks like you’re getting a cheap deal,” he tells Inquirer.
“It is a bit of an illusion. Any young person buying should be working out their finances on the basis that interest rates might rise at least 2 or 3 per cent in the coming decade.”
Disney notes that the ratio of house prices to household income has nearly doubled during the past 15 years. In the 1950s, the average house in Australia’s capital cities cost three years of average earnings; today it costs seven years of average earnings. And two-thirds of low-income households are now spending 30 per cent of their disposable income on housing: the benchmark for “housing stress”. Unless house prices keep falling, and faster, only those with secure jobs and good incomes, or a handout from a generous relative, will be able to buy their own home.
“We’ve still got a huge home purchase affordability problem and people are going to find it very hard to get into it unless they very unwisely over-extend themselves, or can seek family assistance,” Disney warns.
“The potential for serious family rifts arising in that situation is very great if the child can’t pay it back. It’s very dangerous.”
Disney is pleased the federal government is phasing out the first-home buyers bonus, arguing that it merely inflated prices by lining vendors’ pockets and luring low-income earners deeper into debt.
His solution? Stop dreaming. Long-term rentals, common in Europe, would remove the stigma from renting and give lessees greater security than short-term leases, and more flexibility than a mortgage.
“We really should junk the notion that this is the Australian dream because it makes people feel like failures if they’re renting,” Disney says.
DIVING into debt, Katie and Brett Nash are living the great Australian dream.
Having boarded with Katie’s parents for a year to save a deposit, the Brisbane couple borrowed $350,000 to buy a four-bedroom brick house with a big back yard in the outer bayside suburb of Alexandra Hills in Brisbane six weeks ago.
But Brett then lost his job as a cement truck driver, so his wife is spending half her take-home pay as a nurse to meet the $1900-a-month mortgage. Despite the difficulties, the Nashes are delighted they will no longer have to pay “dead rent” to a landlord.
“You’ve got to get into the market some time,” Katie reasons. “It’s for security. We were paying out dead money in rent – I paid $17,000 in rent one year – but buying is an investment.”
Brett, 28, does not feel that his life is any tougher than that of his grandparents’ self-sacrificing generation. “I think a lot of people these days are probably a bit more selfish and want everything,” he says.
“Our grandparents wouldn’t have contemplated things like travelling or spending $500 on a pair of shoes. Nowadays there’s more to be had, and everyone wants everything now.”
The Nashes are among a record number of Australians who took on a mortgage in April, as first-home buyers rushed to cash in on the federal government’s first-home buyers grant ($14,000 for established homes and $21,000 for new properties) before it is phased out from September. Continue reading…